Psychology says people who feel guilty asking friends to return money they borrowed may be struggling with the fear of making a relationship uncomfortable; research across three countries examined why lenders avoid asking for repayment |

1795213643 photo


Psychology says people who feel guilty asking friends to return money they borrowed may be struggling with the fear of making a relationship uncomfortable; research across three countries examined why lenders avoid asking for repayment

Have you ever lent money to a friend, waited weeks or months for them to return it, but hesitated to ask because you did not want to make things awkward? A psychological study suggests that this hesitation may stem from anticipated guilt and the fear of hurting the other person’s feelings. Researchers examined why people sometimes choose not to pursue money they are owed, even when they have a legitimate reason to seek repayment. The findings, based on six studies involving 2,988 participants, suggest that people may prioritise protecting their relationships over their financial interests. The research also found that the amount borrowed and the borrower’s financial circumstances can influence how comfortable lenders feel about requesting their money back.

Why people hesitate to ask friends for their money back

The research, titled Anticipated Guilt and Going Against One’s Self-Interest, was conducted by Xiaolu Zhang, Marcel Zeelenberg and Seger M. Breugelmans. It was published in the peer-reviewed journal Emotion in 2021.The researchers investigated a familiar situation in which someone lends money to a friend, but the borrower fails to return it as promised. Although the lender has a reasonable expectation of getting the money back, initiating a conversation about repayment can create emotional discomfort.In the first study, researchers examined responses from participants in the US, China and the Netherlands. Of the 287 participants whose responses were analysed, 209, or approximately 73%, reported having experienced a situation in which they did not ask for borrowed money back because doing so would make them feel guilty.The finding suggested that concerns about another person’s feelings can influence financial decisions, even when the lender has a legitimate claim to the money.

Anticipated guilt can discourage people from seeking repayment

The second study explored the relationship between anticipated guilt and people’s willingness to ask for their money back.Participants were presented with a hypothetical situation in which a friend had borrowed money, promised to return it within a week and failed to do so even after several weeks.They were asked to consider how guilty they would feel about approaching the borrower and how willing they would be to request repayment.Researchers found a negative correlation between anticipated guilt and willingness to ask for the money. The correlation was -0.46, indicating that participants who expected to feel more guilty were generally less willing to pursue repayment.The findings suggested that people may avoid these conversations because they anticipate the emotional consequences of reminding someone about an unpaid debt.

Smaller loans can make repayment conversations more uncomfortable

The third study examined whether the amount of money borrowed influenced lenders’ willingness to request repayment.Researchers involved 541 participants and presented them with two hypothetical situations. In one, a friend had borrowed $8, while in the other, the amount was $100. In both situations, the borrower had failed to return the money.Participants who imagined lending $8 reported greater anticipated guilt than those who imagined lending $100. Their willingness to ask for repayment was also lower.The average anticipated guilt score was 3.33 for the $8 loan, compared with 2.76 for the $100 loan. Meanwhile, willingness to seek repayment scored 4.55 for the smaller loan and 5.95 for the larger one, on a seven-point scale.Researchers suggested that people may feel more justified in requesting larger amounts because the financial stakes are more significant. With smaller loans, the perceived importance of recovering the money may not outweigh concerns about making the interaction uncomfortable.

A borrower’s financial situation can influence the lender’s decision

Another study examined whether the financial circumstances of the borrower affected the lender’s willingness to ask for repayment.Participants were presented with situations in which a friend had borrowed money but failed to return it. Some were told that the borrower had recently received a substantial amount of money, while others were informed that the person was still experiencing financial difficulties.The results showed that participants anticipated greater guilt when the borrower was financially struggling.The average anticipated guilt score was 4.06 when the borrower was described as financially struggling, compared with 2.31 when the person was financially comfortable. Willingness to request repayment was also lower in the first situation, scoring 4.27 compared with 5.86.The researchers suggested that lenders may be more reluctant to pursue repayment when they believe the borrower is already facing financial difficulties. The possibility of adding to another person’s problems can make an otherwise reasonable request feel emotionally uncomfortable.

Fear of hurting the borrower plays an important role

The final two studies explored why people anticipated guilt when asking for repayment.Researchers examined whether the perceived likelihood of hurting the borrower influenced lenders’ decisions. Participants were presented with different descriptions of borrowers, including situations in which the person was relatively insensitive to reminders and others in which the borrower was more likely to feel hurt.The findings indicated that participants anticipated greater guilt when they believed the borrower would be emotionally affected by a repayment request. They were also less willing to ask for their money in situations where they expected the reminder to cause greater discomfort.This suggested that the reluctance was not necessarily about the act of requesting money itself. Instead, people appeared to be concerned about how the other person might interpret or emotionally respond to the request.

How protecting relationships can take priority over money

The researchers explained their findings through the concept of anticipated guilt, an emotion people expect to experience when they believe their actions could negatively affect someone else.In informal lending arrangements, this can create a conflict between two competing interests. On one hand, lenders want to recover money that belongs to them. On the other, they may want to avoid embarrassing the borrower, creating tension or making an existing friendship uncomfortable.As a result, some people may choose to remain silent rather than initiate a conversation about repayment.The research highlights how financial decisions between friends can be influenced by emotional considerations, with the desire to preserve a relationship sometimes taking priority over recovering money.

A related study examines why borrowers and lenders view small loans differently

A separate study published in 2022 in Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, titled Misaligned Mindsets Between Borrowers and Lenders of Small Interpersonal Loans, examined another aspect of informal lending.Researchers Coby Morvinski and Yaniv Shani conducted six experiments to understand how borrowers and lenders perceive small personal loans.Their findings identified a difference between the two sides. Borrowers often approached these arrangements with an exchange mindset, viewing the money as a loan that should eventually be returned. Lenders, meanwhile, were more likely to adopt a communal mindset, sometimes treating smaller amounts as informal assistance rather than strictly transactional exchanges.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *